In breaking news, here is a transcript of, and audio recording by, former St. Tammany Parish Library Board of Control member William (Bill) R. McHugh, III, speaking with St. Tammany Parish Council District 13 Councilman Jeff Corbin, pictured top right. This recording was intended for use in a lawsuit Mr. McHugh just lost big as described here:
- "ALA Loses in Louisiana US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit: Parr v Cougle," by Dan Kleinman, SafeLibraries, 11 February 2025.
The recording was discussed in local media here:
- "After Dustup Between Republicans, St. Tammany Council Elects Jeff Corbin as Vice Chair," by Willie Swett, NOLA.com, 7 December 2024.
And here is the telephone conversation and its politically-charged nature discussed by Citizens for a New Louisiana on 19 November 2024:
Now, below is the transcript and here is the transcript and full recording synched together for your listening and re-listening pleasure: TRANSCRIPT AND RECORDING BY BILL McHUGH OF JEFF CORBIN HERE [CENSORED PER ORDER OF DISTRICT ATTORNEY, 22ND JUDICIAL DISTRICT, WASHINGTON — ST. TAMMANY PARISHES, CIVIL DIVISION, 214954 KOOP DR, 2G, MANDEVILLE LA 70471].
It's very rare to see a politician, Republican, no less, and a library board member so interested in keeping kids exposed to inappropriate material that they feel people must serve on and stay on library boards to keep out the Christians and the Trump supporters who oppose harming children per American Library Association's 60 years of effort. But there it is, res ipsa loquitur.
It happens all the time, it's just rare that it got recorded, reported, and we get to see it. Sad. Were I residing there, I know for whom I wouldn't vote, nor for any of their supporters or supporting library "alliances," especially not the one ALA created.
TRANSCRIPT:
[CENSORED PER ORDER OF DISTRICT ATTORNEY, 22ND JUDICIAL DISTRICT, WASHINGTON — ST. TAMMANY PARISHES, CIVIL DIVISION, 214954 KOOP DR, 2G, MANDEVILLE LA 70471]
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
[inaudible 00:06:34]
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
[inaudible 00:07:18]
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
[inaudible 00:09:05]
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
[inaudible 00:13:35].
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
(laughs).
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
[NOTE: redacted for privacy].
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
[NOTE: redacted for privacy].
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
[NOTE: redacted for privacy]
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
William (Bill) R. McHugh, III:
Jeff Corbin:
NOTE ADDED 5 MARCH 2025:
Apparently I'm such a good investigative reporter that I have been ordered to censor my report. So I did.
Once ALA wanted me to remove something I published, but I didn't, so go read what Chicago's ALA wanted censored and doesn't want you to read:
- "Gay Hate @ Your Library," by Dan Kleinman, SafeLibraries, 27 July 2014.
This time the censorship request comes from a legitimate source and for a legitimate-sounding reason, as opposed to ALA trying to hide its own internalized homophobia, that is still has, by the way. I don't believe I've distributed this material past an email or so to governmental leaders in the Parishes and this publication, and I'm deleting the text and any associated links from this post. I will not provide the transcript/audio to anyone even if asked. I'm aiming to fully comply with the cease and desist letter posted below. And I wish all parties and all sides well.
CENSORED PER ORDER OF DISTRICT ATTORNEY, 22ND JUDICIAL DISTRICT, WASHINGTON — ST. TAMMANY PARISHES, CIVIL DIVISION, 214954 KOOP DR, 2G, MANDEVILLE LA 70471
Given the following, I'll be publishing the censorship order in full: "Any e-mail may be construed as a public document, and may be subject to a public records request. The contents of this e-mail reflect the opinion of the writer, and are not necessarily the opinion or policy of the 22nd Judicial District Attorney’s Office or St. Tammany Parish Government."
Cease and Desist Letter
J. Collin Sims
District Attorney
22nd Judicial District
Washington – St. Tammany Parishes
Civil Division Telephone: (985) 898-3427
214954 Koop Drive, 2G Fax: (985) 867-5124
Mandeville, LA 70471
Dan Kleinman
641 Shunpike Rd #123, Chatham, NJ 07928
Phone: 973-610-8296
SafeLibraries@pm.me
VIA EMAIL
Re: Anthony Parr; et al, Plaintiffs—Appellees, v. David Cougle, et al Defendant—Appellant, Kathy Seiden et al. Docket No. 24-30523
Dear Mr. Kleinman:
In the case referenced above, the District Attorney for St. Tammany Parish very recently
successfully litigated the question of whether the recordings of conversations between two St.
Tammany Parish Councilmembers and Bill McHugh are protected by the legislative privilege. The
Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals held that the privilege applied. In light of this ruling, in our view,
the material that is covered by the privilege is similar to intellectual property or material protected
by copyright laws. Absent express permission from the holder of the privilege, any use of material
protected by the privilege without authority is actionable.
Because the Councilmembers whose conversations were recorded did not release the
recordings to the public, and did not give you express permission to post the recordings, your use
of the recordings and transcripts of the recordings and transmission of the recordings and
transcripts to third parties is a violation of the legislative privilege. Please consider this to be a
formal demand for you to immediately cease publishing the recordings and transcripts on the
internet, and to cease transmitting the recordings and transcripts to third parties in any form,
electronic or otherwise. We ask that the post be taken down within 24 hours of your receipt of this
correspondence. If you fail to comply, we will seek recourse against you in the courts. Thank you
in advance for your anticipated cooperation.
Respectfully,
/s/
___________________________________
James J. Bolner, Jr.
Assistant District Attorney
If anyone wishes to help in my legal efforts to defend against a Louisiana school librarian, please do:
—
URL of this page:
Bottom line - With the ease of inappropriate books ( geared to attract children) we, as responsible Christian parents and educators, will do what it takes to keep children that roam library shelves protected from this content.
ReplyDeleteIf you are referring to LGBTQ books you find offensive, you are practicing your faith incorrectly. As Christians we love each other as the Bible tells us to do. Our faith teaches us not to judge. Parent your children and love thy neighbor
DeleteIt's hilarious that this is an issue when most children are walking around with unrestricted internet access in the palms of their hands.
ReplyDeleteAnd you're worried about books in the adult section.
The commentary at the top of this post is filled with misinformation… a common occurrence in conservative media.
ReplyDeletePlease specify so I may address your concerns.
DeleteFurther, opposition to Chicago, Illinois, trained librarians harming children nationwide is not a "conservative" issue. Every side opposes that. All sides oppose that. Democrats, for example, oppose that.
It's a tiny, tiny minority of ALA Chicago-trained librarians and their astroturfed supporters who are in favor of ALA's approximately 60 year efforts to indoctrinate and s3xualize school children right in their schools and public libraries.