The evidence is an email to libraries throughout Illinois by Deborah Caldwell-Stone, Esq., the Deputy Director of the ALA's Office for Intellectual Freedom. This order to destroy documents is out and open incitement to violate various open government laws, and to cover up ALA's "exposure." And almost everyone complied, but not all.
That this incitement was done knowingly and purposefully is evident from the lawyer's use of her private email address instead of her ALA email address, similar to the actions of former EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson, a.k.a. "Richard Windsor."
And all to hide her Office's homophobia and ALA's ordering librarians to destroy evidence of crime in libraries and calls not to record such evidence in the first place. This is documented in a frightened librarian's email I published at "Brave Librarian Speaks Out as ALA Facilitates CHILD P[]rn." She revealed, among other shocking things, "Blondie said that Orland was focusing only on you and ignoring your friend because he is gay and it gets messy to attack a gay guy. .... I also remember that a jab was made at you ... that you should not be hanging out all day with a gay guy with your kids anyway." To me, those are homophobic statements, particularly the latter. ALA's Deborah Caldwell-Stone, Esq., then rehired this homophobic trainer for more of the same training. (The trainer dropped the gig when this was exposed.) That's one more thing that makes ALA homophobic—no one who isn't homophobic knowingly hires homophobic trainers who teach homophobia—but ALA did.
Of possible interest, the trainer went on to sue me twice in federal court, losing both times, and a settlement offer was made that the case would be dropped if I censored this publication revealing ALA's homophobia: "Gay Hate @ Your Library." So go read what ALA's censorship police tried to censor about themselves via its homophobic proxy.
Below is a series of my messages on this topic, followed by the actual text of the damning email from ALA's lawyer:
About to tweet entire email by @ALALibrary's @OIF for #librarians to destroy public documents in violation of the law + #FOIA #libchat— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-01
"Subject: URGENT - must delete all documents related to 17 Dec crisis communications workshop"— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-02
"Date: Friday, April 4, 2014 at 4:46:24 PM Central Daylight Time"— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-03
"From: dcs47@hushmail.com— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
To: nbennyhoff@illinoisheartland.org"
"DCS47" = Deborah Caldwell-Stone, Esq., Deputy Director of @OIF
-04
#ALA's @OIF is using a personal email address to TRY to protect @ALALibrary from being involved in this public data destruction scheme.— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-05
DCS47 @OIF = an Illinois attorney literally advising #librarians to destroy public documents. #FOIA @ISBAlawyer @LisaMadigan @ECWDogs— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-06
NOTE: document I'm tweeting was received in response to a #FOIA request for emails sent to @OrlandPkLibrary #library. #FoiaFriday— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-07
"In case you are not yet aware there is a situation where we have exposure related to the 17 Dec crisis communications workshop …"— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-08
"…facilitated by RAILS. We are under scrutiny and FOIA requests went out this morning fishing for documents and video."— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-09
"Remove these from your servers today and destroy hard copies. This is an attempt by two individuals to obtain privileged information…"— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-10
"…from the event. It does not appear this is much more than a hunch on the part of requesters but we should not retain any materials …"— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-11
"…from the event as a precaution. As this was a candid and private function not meant for the public it would be best if we purge …"— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-12
"…any records any of us have related to the event. Taking parts of discussion out of context would be harmful so we cannot allow…"— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-13
"…anything from 17 Dec to be produced in response to FOIA."— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-14
"TAKING PARTS OF DISCUSSION OUT OF CONTEXT WOULD BE HARMFUL SO WE CANNOT ALLOW ANYTHING FROM 17 DEC TO BE PRODUCED IN RESPONSE TO FOIA"— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-15
"Cannot allow"? The American Library Association @ALALibrary's @OIF has the power to tell local #libraries not to comply with #FOIA?— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-16
Note that part of what @ALALibrary's @OIF is hiding is its use of #homophobia to train #librarians. #lgbt #gay #h8 @TheAdvocateMag— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-17
"It is advisable to be proactive here and get ahead of this before the individuals gain traction." #FF @MeganFoxWriter @StoryTimeDigita— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-18
"The OPPL has already been served with a FOIA and it appears the requesters are working down a list and serving the rest of us."— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-19
So @ALALibrary's @OIF knows @OrlandPkLibrary's biz but OPPL hides that connection in #FOIA responses. @MeganFoxWriter @StoryTimeDigita— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-20
"These are the same two individuals who have been causing problems since October. They will make hay out of anything they obtain."— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-21
"Do not facilitate this in any way."— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
In other words, do not comply with #FOIA, and indeed @OrlandPkLibrary has spent ~$500K on this!
-22
"Leslie at IHLS and Brian at RAILS should run point on deleting all materials before FOIAs are served." #FOIA #FoiaFriday— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-23
"There is still time to get ahead of this if we act today. Deny, delete, defend. – dcs"— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
DENY, DELETE, DEFEND#libchat @LibraryJournal
-24
Public #librarians attended and it was taped for rebroadcast to #library trustees, so this was not a "private function." @ala_united— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-25
DELETE— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
DENY
DEFEND
That's @ALALibrary's @OIF's ATTORNEY telling public officials on public business to destroy public documents.
-26
This concludes my tweeting @ALALibrary's @OIF ordering local #libraries to destroy public data and deny #opengov #FOIA #CivilRights.— Dan Kleinman (@SafeLibraries) August 7, 2015
-27
Here is the actual email from Deborah Caldwell-Stone, Esq., Deputy Director of American Library Association's "Office for Intellectual Freedom" and, when you read the email by "dcs," you'll know why I put quotation marks around "Office for Intellectual Freedom" (emphasis added):
Subject: URGENT - must delete all documents related to 17 Dec crisis communications workshop
Date: Friday, April 4, 2014 at 4:46:24 PM Central Daylight Time
From: dcs47@hushmail.com
To: nbennyhoff@illinoisheartland.org
[NOTE: BCCs are not shown, but this document was received in response to a FOIA request for emails sent to Orland Park Public Library, Orland Park, IL, [OPPL]’s director Mary Weimar and OPPL’s public relations employee Bridget Bittman]
In case you are not yet aware there is a situation where we have exposure related to the 17 Dec crisis communications workshop facilitated by RAILS. We are under scrutiny and FOIA requests went out this morning fishing for documents and video. Remove these from your servers today and destroy hard copies. This is an attempt by two individuals to obtain privileged information from the event. It does not appear this is much more than a hunch on the part of requesters but we should not retain any materials from the event as a precaution. As this was a candid and private function not meant for the public it would be best if we purge any records any of us have related to the event. Taking parts of discussion out of context would be harmful so we cannot allow anything from 17 Dec to be produced in response to FOIA. It is advisable to be proactive here and get ahead of this before the individuals gain traction. The OPPL has already been served with a FOIA and it appears the requesters are working down a list and serving the rest of us. These are the same two individuals who have been causing problems since October. They will make hay out of anything they obtain. Do not facilitate this in any way. Leslie at IHLS and Brian at RAILS should run point on deleting all materials before FOIAs are served. There is still time to get ahead of this if we act today. Deny, delete, defend. - dcs
The above is based in part on work I originally published in 2015 as "Deny, Delete, Defend; American Library Association Orders Public Librarians To Destroy Public Documents To Preclude Public Disclosure of its 'Exposure'" on Storify which has since announced it is closing and removing all content. Hence the need to record this information here.
And ALA has yet to suffer any consequences for its own homophobia, its hiding its own homophobia, and calling for library crimes to be hidden from the public and for whistleblowers to be attacked verbally and financially, which actually happened to me.
The above is all my opinion, as usual, but backed up with evidence anyone can see.
—
URL of this page:
safelibraries.blogspot.com/2018/04/librarians-ordered-to-destroy.html
On Twitter:
@ALALibrary @OIF @OrlandPkLibrary
Follow @SafeLibraries
safelibraries.blogspot.com/2018/04/librarians-ordered-to-destroy.html
On Twitter:
@ALALibrary @OIF @OrlandPkLibrary
Follow @SafeLibraries